OUT OF VOICE REACH - Chapter 4 - The Outlying School Boy

OUT OF VOICE REACH - Chapter 4 - The Outlying School Boy | Travelling Around Australia with Jeff Banks

The outlying school boy carried more than a schoolbag. He carried the farm road, the primary school bus rides, the related children who were still not quite his people, the marks that impressed adults and separated him from classmates, and the sporting hopes that gave him a place only while he kept earning it. He carried all of that into secondary school and then, without quite noticing, carried it into the rest of his life.

OUT OF VOICE REACH

A life spent trying to belong

Chapter 4 – The Outlying School Boy

By the time I went to secondary school, I already understood that distance could be carried inside you. It was not just the twenty miles from home to town, or the bus route, or the long road that had to be travelled before the school day even began. It was the small, stubborn knowledge that I came from somewhere else, somewhere beyond the ordinary map of the children who lived close enough to school to treat it as part of their natural world.

Primary school had given me a version of belonging, but it had always been conditional. I was there, but not quite “of there”. I shared classrooms with children who were related to one another, children whose families seemed to overlap at every fence line, every gate, every Sunday visit and every town event, while I came in from beyond the edge of that circle and went back out again at the end of the day. I could do the work, and I could compete on the sports field, but neither of those things fully changed the fact that I arrived from somewhere else.

Secondary school sharpened that feeling rather than softened it. The move was supposed to be a step forward, as these things always are in the language of adults, but to me it felt like being taken from one small test and dropped into a larger one. Suddenly there were more children, more groups already formed, more ways to be measured, and more ways to be found wanting before you had even opened your mouth.

Being from an outlying school carried its own quiet stigma. No one needed to make a formal announcement of it, because children are much more efficient than adults at organising people into ranks. You knew who came from town, who came from the better-known schools, who had brothers and sisters already there, who had cousins waiting under trees or leaning against walls, and who arrived looking as though they had been delivered from another district entirely. I was not exactly a foreigner, but I was near enough to one for schoolyard purposes.

The town children seemed to know the rules before the game began. They knew where to stand, who to talk to, who mattered, which teachers were feared and which could be managed, and which boys already had a reputation worth borrowing. I had to learn it all while pretending I was not learning it. There is a particular kind of exhaustion in being new and trying not to look new, especially when you suspect that looking unsure is the first thing others will use against you.

The bus ride was part of it, of course. It is hard to feel like an insider when every day begins and ends with a reminder that you have come from a long way out. The road in was not simply transport; it was a daily procession from one identity to another. At home I was a boy from a grazing property, useful in the ways country children were expected to become useful, but by the time I reached school I had to become something else again, something acceptable to a crowd that had already decided what acceptable looked like.

I have often thought that country distance does something strange to childhood. It gives you space, but it also teaches you separation. It teaches you self-reliance, but sometimes before you are old enough to know what loneliness is called. You learn to manage silence, to make your own company, to watch adults carefully, and to measure your words before releasing them into the air. That might be good training for survival, but it is not always good training for walking into a schoolyard full of noise and certainty.

Academic work gave me one kind of footing. I could sit in a classroom and understand things quickly, and there was comfort in that because books and sums and written answers did not care where I came from. They did not ask who my cousins were, or how close I lived to town, or whether I knew the private jokes that had been built over years before I arrived. A correct answer was a correct answer, and for a while that seemed like a fairer world.

But being good at schoolwork brought its own trouble. It gave me stature, perhaps, but not ease. There is a difference between being respected and being accepted, and I began to learn that difference early. A boy who does well in class may be useful to teachers and irritating to other boys, and sometimes the very thing that proves you belong in one room makes you a target in another.

I do not want to pretend I was persecuted every minute of every day, because that would be too simple and not entirely true. There were decent moments, ordinary laughs, games played, conversations had, and days that passed without drama. But there was always a sense of needing to be careful, of needing to earn my place rather than assume it. Other boys seemed to inherit their position; I felt as though I had to invoice for mine daily, with no guarantee of payment.

Sport offered another route in, though it too came with conditions. On a field, a court, or a pitch, the rules were clearer than they were in the schoolyard. If you could run, hit, tackle, catch, ride, or compete, then for a short time you were judged by something visible. That suited me because I had already learned how to strive, and striving was easier to understand than belonging.

There was relief in sport because it gave me a job to do. I did not have to explain myself when the ball was coming my way, or when there was a race to be run, or when a contest asked more of the body than of social confidence. In those moments I could become useful, and usefulness has always been a dangerous substitute for love or acceptance. It feels close enough to belonging that you can mistake it for the real thing.

The trouble was that sport also taught me the next level of conditional belonging. If I was good, I was noticed. If I was better, I was selected. If I was selected, then I belonged to the team, but only while I continued to justify the selection. There was no resting in it, no simple pleasure in being one of the boys, because success seemed to carry a silent clause at the bottom of the page: keep proving it.

Representative sport made that contradiction even sharper. Cricket in the Southern Tablelands, rugby league in Western Division, and the other honours that came along the way should have felt like clean triumphs. In some ways they did, because I would be lying if I said there was no pride in being chosen. A jumper, a cap, a team sheet, a bus trip to another town, all of that mattered to a boy who wanted evidence that he was not invisible.

Yet each step outward also made me more exposed. The further I went, the more I seemed to move away from the very belonging I was trying to find. Being selected could bring praise from adults, but it could also bring sideways looks from those who thought you were getting above yourself. Achievement had a funny way of lifting you just high enough for others to take aim.

That is one of the crueler lessons of growing up outside the circle. You imagine that if you can just do enough, win enough, achieve enough, then the gates will open and someone will say, “Righto, you’ve earned your place.” But life rarely works with that sort of decency. More often, achievement changes the shape of the exclusion rather than removing it. You stop being ignored and start being judged.

Horse riding added another layer to it. Coming from a grazing property, horses were not exotic or decorative; they were part of the landscape, part of the work, part of the way a child learned balance, nerve, and consequence. If you rode well, it was not simply a hobby to be admired, but another measure of competence expected of you. Even there, where I might have seemed most naturally at home, success could set me apart rather than settle me in.

I can look back now and see that I was trying to build a case for myself. The classroom, the sports field, the cricket pitch, the rugby league ground, the horse arena, each one became another witness called on my behalf. I was trying to prove I was worth including, even though I would never have used those words at the time. Boys do not usually speak that way, especially country boys, and certainly not boys who have already learned to hide hurt behind effort.

There is a particular loneliness in being competent. People assume competence is confidence, and sometimes it is, but often it is only armour worn often enough to fit the body. If you can do things, people ask more of you. If you keep delivering, they assume you are all right. The boy who keeps achieving can disappear behind the achievements, and everyone can admire the scoreboard while missing the child standing behind it.

At secondary school, I began to understand that being noticed was not the same as being known. Teachers might know my marks, coaches might know my ability, and classmates might know where I fitted in the rough order of things, but that did not mean they knew me. I am not sure I knew myself either. I knew what I could do, but I was less certain of who I was when there was nothing to prove.

That question has followed me for much of my life. It has turned up in work, in business, in community roles, in family responsibilities, and now at the edge of retirement, where the old tools suddenly look less reliable than they once did. For years, if I felt uncertain, I could work harder. If I felt unseen, I could become useful. If I felt outside, I could earn my way closer to the door, even if I never quite stepped through it.

Secondary school did not create that pattern, but it gave it a wider stage. It showed me that the rules of primary school had not been an accident. The world was not going to simply notice the boy from out wide and gather him in out of kindness. If I wanted a place, I would need to make myself hard to dismiss, and that is a tiring lesson to learn before you have even properly grown into your shoulders.

I sometimes wonder what would have happened if I had been ordinary at everything. That is not false modesty, nor is it pride dressed up as reflection. It is a genuine question. If I had not been good academically, if I had not found sport as an outlet, if I had not had the stubbornness to keep pushing, would I have disappeared more completely, or would I have been spared the burden of constantly being measured against my last performance?

There is no answer to that, of course. We only get the life we lived, not the alternative version with cleaner edges. I was good at some things, and those things helped me survive. They also taught me to confuse performance with belonging, which is not a lesson easily unlearned. Once you begin to believe that your value depends on what you can deliver, rest starts to feel suspicious.

The boys from town may have had their own burdens, and I understand that more clearly now than I could then. Every child carries something, even the ones who seem comfortably placed in the centre of things. But at the time, from where I stood, they seemed to move with a confidence I did not possess. They belonged by geography, by family, by familiarity, while I belonged only by result.

That kind of comparison can twist itself into you. You begin to watch for signs that you are being tolerated rather than welcomed. You become alert to laughter, not because laughter is always cruel, but because you have learned that it might be. You hear your own background in the way others say the name of your school or district, as though distance itself has made you less polished, less certain, or less likely to understand the proper rules of the place.

The stigma of the outlying school was not always shouted. Often it lived in tone, in assumption, in the faint surprise that you could do well. It was there when people underestimated you, and sometimes it was there when they overpraised you, because both responses carried the same message: you were not quite what they expected from where you came from. That is a strange thing for a child to absorb, being treated as both less than and unusually successful, depending on what suited the observer.

I learned to answer it with effort. That was my habit, and perhaps my refuge. If there was a test, I would do well. If there was a team, I would try to make it. If there was a contest, I would compete hard enough that no one could say I had not earned my place. It was a simple system, almost brutally simple, and for a long time I mistook its simplicity for wisdom.

But effort has a cost when it is driven by the fear of being dismissed. It can look admirable from the outside, and people will often applaud it because people enjoy the sight of determination when they are not paying the bill for it. Inside, though, it can become a kind of restlessness that never quite leaves you alone. You learn to keep going even when tired, to say yes when you are already stretched, and to measure quiet days as though they are evidence of failure.

I can see the beginnings of that in the secondary school boy who travelled twenty miles to start again. He did not have the words for depression, or masking, or identity, and I am glad in one sense because those words can sometimes make a boy feel more examined than understood. What he had was a heaviness that came and went, a stubborn streak, a desire to be seen, and a fear that being seen too clearly might bring more pain than comfort.

So he pushed on. He did the work, played the sport, took the field, rode the horse, accepted the praise, absorbed the mockery, and kept pretending that the two cancelled each other out. They did not. Praise and hurt do not balance neatly like figures in a ledger, no matter how much the accountant in me might wish they did. Some things sit on opposite sides of the page for years without ever reconciling.

The representative jumper is a good symbol for that time. It should have meant belonging, and in one way it did. For the length of a match or a carnival, I was part of something larger than myself, wearing colours that said I had been chosen. But the jumper also reminded me that belonging could be issued, withdrawn, and replaced by the next selection trial. It was not home; it was temporary accommodation.

That is why I have never been able to write about those years as simple success. The facts might suggest achievement, and I do not deny them. There was pride in doing well, and there were moments of joy, excitement, satisfaction, and perhaps even belonging. But running underneath was the older current, the boy from the farm, seven miles from the nearest settlement, out of voice reach, still wondering whether anyone could hear him properly.

Secondary school widened the world, but it did not bring me neatly inside it. It showed me more rooms, more gates, more teams, more ladders to climb, and more people whose approval seemed worth chasing. I became better at the chase. I learned how to look capable, how to make myself useful, how to achieve enough that others had to make room for me, at least for a while.

Looking back, I feel both tenderness and frustration for that boy. Tenderness because he was doing the best he could with the tools he had, and frustration because some of those tools would later become cages. Achievement kept him moving, but it also taught him to fear stillness. Competence gave him respect, but it sometimes robbed him of the chance to be simply accepted without having to perform first.

There are memories from that time that remain clear, not because they were dramatic, but because they carried the shape of the whole thing. The bus pulling in at school, the movement of bodies toward their familiar groups, the feeling of scanning for a place to stand without looking as though I was scanning. The classroom where I could breathe because the work made sense, and the yard where nothing made quite as much sense at all. The sports ground where I could run hard enough to forget myself, until the whistle blew and I had to become myself again.

Perhaps that is why the phrase Out of Voice Reach still matters to me. It began as a description of where we lived, a practical fact about distance between farms and neighbours. But by secondary school it had become something else, though I would not have known how to say it then. I was within sight of people every day, shoulder to shoulder with them in classrooms, buses, teams and assemblies, yet still beyond the place where my voice felt naturally heard.

I do not want to overstate the tragedy of it, because there is a dry humour in the whole business too. I can almost see the younger version of myself, jaw set, determined to prove everyone wrong while desperately hoping someone would save him the trouble. There is something very Australian about pretending not to care while caring so much it nearly wears you out. We are a strange people that way, excellent at understatement and not always brilliant at tenderness.

Still, that boy survived, and more than survived. He learned, competed, achieved, and built a kind of strength from the very distance that hurt him. But survival is not the same as peace, and strength is not always the same as belonging. Those are distinctions I have had to learn slowly, usually the hard way, and often after insisting for too long that I was fine.

The outlying school boy carried more than a schoolbag. He carried the farm road, the primary school bus rides, the related children who were still not quite his people, the marks that impressed adults and separated him from classmates, and the sporting hopes that gave him a place only while he kept earning it. He carried all of that into secondary school and then, without quite noticing, carried it into the rest of his life.

I suppose that is the point of this chapter, if chapters are allowed to have points without becoming sermons. The boy who travelled twenty miles to secondary school was not just moving from one school to another. He was being taught, again and again, that belonging was something to be worked for, guarded, justified and renewed. It would take me much of a lifetime to question whether that lesson was true, and even longer to imagine that there might be another way to live.

Author

Menu